Best Italian Restaurant in Reynoldsburg, Columbus, OH

Experience Hearty Italian Classics In A Warm Atmosphere
Traditional Italian Meals for the Family

Traditional Italian Meals for the Family

Milano's is a family-run eatery in East Pointe that has served the Columbus community for over 40 years. We focus on hearty servings of classic Italian dishes made fresh every day. Our dining room is warm and cozy, making it the perfect spot for families and couples to relax. We value tradition and use high-quality ingredients in every meal. Come visit us for a friendly meal and great service today.
Hearty Pasta and Italian Classic Dishes

Hearty Pasta and Italian Classic Dishes

Our menu features time-tested recipes that locals love. The lasagna is our best seller, layered with care and baked until perfect. We also serve classic spaghetti with meatballs and creamy fettuccine alfredo for a comforting meal. If you want something hearty, try our chicken parmesan. We also offer fresh seafood and choice-cut steaks. Every dish is prepared to ensure you have a great dining experience with us. Our kitchen team works hard to keep these classic flavors consistent for every guest.
Award-Winning Dining Experience

Award-Winning Dining Experience

We’re proud to have been named Best Restaurant in Reynoldsburg (2025) by 614 Magazine, Columbus’ leading foodie publication. This recognition reflects our commitment to exceptional flavors, quality ingredients, and an unforgettable dining experience.

Fresh Italian Food Delivered to You

Enjoy your favorite Italian meals at home with our simple online ordering system. We offer quick takeout and reliable delivery for your convenience. Just pick your dishes, checkout on our website, and we will handle the rest. It is the fastest way to get a fresh meal on your table.

Here’s a sneak peek of the items our customers can’t stop talking about

Visit Us in the Heart of East Pointe

Address: 6916 E Broad St, Columbus, OH 43213 Mon – Fri: 11 am – 9 pm Saturday: 4 pm – 9 pm Sunday: Closed Happy Hour: Mon – Fri, 4 pm – 6 pm Features: Cozy fireplace, private dining, and a warm family atmosphere.

What our guests are saying

Our dinner was well prepared. I had liver and onions with a side of spaghetti and wedding soup. I asked for a medium cook on the liver, and it was perfect. My wife had homemade spaghetti and meatballs. She enjoyed it, too. The menu has a good selection.

David C.

David C.

A lovely little Italian place. Stopped in there for lunch; it was our first visit to that restaurant. I had veal parmesan, and my bride had the eggplant parmesan; both were excellent. Furthermore, the staff was friendly and attentive. If it were closer to home, I'd be a regular patron.

Mark P.

Mark P.

We always have a wonderful meal here! Huge portion sizes and always fresh. From the appetiser to the salad, meal and dessert, we were happy with everything! Our server was also friendly and attentive.

Christina W.

Christina W.

Featuring

Catering

Delivery

Takeout

Dine In

Happy-Hour Food

Fireplace

Private Dining Room

Columbus Foodies Member Perks

Columbus Foodies Member Perks

Columbus Foodies members enjoy special savings when dining with us. Simply present your discount card at the restaurant when ordering and unlock exclusive offers on your favorite dishes.

Milano's Italian Restaurant Rewards

Join our rewards programme, earn points every time you order online, and redeem your points for free food!

Our location

Map showing the location of Milano's | Italian Restaurant on 6916 E Broad St in Columbus

Loading today's hours...